October 18, 2008

  • For the “Health” of the Mother

    It’s taken me a couple days to calm down enough to write about this so I’m sure that quite a few people who have said it better have already weighed in on this.  But I want to talk about what I thought/felt when McCain, during the presidential debate, did this little wriggling fingers “air quotes” around the phrase “the health of the mother” to mock Senator Obama’s position in answer to the question about overturning Roe v Wade.

    The medical definition of abortion is “the premature ending of a pregnancy.”

    By that definition, I’ve had 3 abortions.

    2 spontaneous abortions in which for reasons known only to God, my body aborted the pregnancy and left me grieving. 

    The 3rd case is one in which I and my Doctor chose to end the pregnancy.  I was not quite 8 months along.  I first developed pre-eclampsia and then the full-blown condition.  My blood pressure was running 160/110 and I was in imminent danger of stroke in spite of having religiously followed the Dr’s orders to be on complete bed rest for 2 months.  (Pre-eclampsia kills about 70,000 women worldwide each year, and the reason that number isn’t a whole lot higher is because modern medical practice gives women choices that they’ve never had before.) 

    I entered the hospital on the day that O J Simpson was doing his surreal slow-motion run from the cops on national television.  I watched CNN with my face averted from the nurse who was administering the medication that would soften my cervix for the procedure to take place the next day. 

    The next morning my Dr. asked me if I was ready and then she broke my water. 

    Six hours later, Michael Caleb was born.

    He was tiny, and he wasn’t in great shape.  The doctor took my husband aside and explained to him that I was still in danger of dying from stroke and outlined exactly what would have to be done to give me and my son the best chance of survival.  And we followed her orders. 

    My story has a happy ending as do the stories of many women across this country every day who have to choose to either continue a pregnancy at great risk to themselves and their babies, or “aborting”. 

    When Senator McCain made that mocking gesture, it was a slap in my face.

    I believe that going on and on about overturning Roe v Wade is a dangerous distraction that enables politicians to cloak themselves in the garb of righteousness while doing nothing to actually change anything. 

    If we are going to see a reduction in “birth-control” abortions, we are going to have to address the conditions that prompt women to make that choice. 

    The most common reasons that teens and young women choose to have
    an abortion include:

    • Awareness that they are not mature enough to
      have a child.
    • Knowledge that they are financially not able to
      support or care for a child.
    • Concern that having a baby would
      change their lives and compromise their (and a child’s) future-many young
      mothers don’t ever manage to get the education and employment necessary to
      raise their child above the poverty line.

    The most common reasons women consider abortion are:

    • Birth control (contraceptive) failure. Over
      half of all women who have an abortion used a contraceptive method during the
      month they became pregnant.
    • Inability to
      support or care for a child.
    • To end an unwanted
      pregnancy.
    • To prevent the birth of a child with birth defects or
      severe medical problems.
    • Pregnancy resulting from rape or
      incest.
    • Physical or mental conditions that endanger the woman’s health if
      the pregnancy is continued.

    If we are going to make a difference, we need to stop talking and start working.  We are going to have to make it possible for young women to get medical care.  (Do you wonder how many of the 45 million uninsured Americans might become pregnant this year?)  We are going to have to make it possible for them to continue their education even if they are mothers.  We are going to have to make it possible for them to have employment that will enable them to support themselves and their child(ren).  We are going to have to create affordable, safe, housing options. 

    When Barack Obama pointed to the fact that the Democratic Platform includes a call for policies and practices that will address these things, he was talking about actually doing something to make a difference.  When Senator McCain mocked a woman’s “health” he showed a contempt for the reality of what it means to be a pregnant woman in this country. 

    We are going to have to get over our fear that some “welfare mom” somewhere is going to take advantage of the system and somehow enrich herself at taxpayer expense.  We need to wake up to the fact that welfare reform has created conditions in the United States of America in which over 18 percent of all children under the age of 18 live in poverty.  If we want to see birth-control abortion rates go down, we are going to have to go to battle against the conditions that create a climate in which women feel they have no choice.  If we can spend trillions of dollars on a war against terrorism, or a rescue of the economy, how about just a couple billion for childcare?  Or health care?  Small business loans?  Educational grants?  Affordable housing programs?

    Proposing, even passing laws making it illegal for women to have abortions doesn’t solve the problem.  It worsens the problem because it makes the assumption that all women who would elect to end a pregnancy prematurely are doing so as a means of birth control.  It removes the ability to exercise control over our health from individual women and our doctors and places it in the hands of the state.    

    A law prohibiting “late term abortions” would most likely have cost me my life, and the life of my son.  That’s not a call I’m willing for any politician to make on my behalf. 

Comments (14)

  • During the debate, I was practically cheering Obama on.  He talked about keeping it legal but reducing those outside factors and increasing support for women.  I thought it was wonderful. And because I respect McCain, I expected more from him in his response.  His flippant righteousness was too much.  I’ve been an Obama supporter for two years now, but I’ve always thought McCain was a good man and good for the country.  He deeply saddened me with his callousness.

  • You are the first woman I’ve ever heard talk first hand about abortion.  Thank you for telling your experience.  It does us good to hear what others have gone through.  I’m pro-life for myself, but have never thought that I should decide for someone else.  Thanks again.

  • the hardcore pro-lifers were peeing their pants with glee, i’m sure. while the rest of us were “appalled”.

    my pro-life family says that women don’t really get pregnant by rape and incest. i say, tell that to the fourteen year old girl, pregnant by her father, who i accompanied to the clinic. then they tell me i’m going to hell. it’s a vicious circle.

  • I believe that going on and on about overturning Roe v Wade is a
    dangerous distraction that enables politicians to cloak themselves in
    the garb of righteousness while doing nothing to actually change
    anything.

    Perfectly stated.
    Thank you for writing this. Thank you for speaking up. Well done!

  • Exactly! McCain managed to lose the last of the respect I had for him with that whole thing. I’m still not wild about Obama, but McCain is out of the picture with me.

  • I appreciate this blog and your clarity and honesty. I also appreciate your commentor nannaruth, her very lovely thoughts of you while agreeing to disagree. We can compromise without risking and destroying lives.

  • See! This is why you should vote for me for president! I think the decision to abort should belong to mission control. If they feel there is eminant danger to any of the astronauts, the launch should be aborted, but if all systems are go then the launch should ensue. I don’t think the govornement has the right to determine whether or not the launch is safe or timing is right. I think the astronauts and the flight control specialists should make the decision as they see fit. 

  • @Aloysius_son - You’re definitely in the margin of error in the latest poll of my house. 

  • Gee, I could go ON and ON and ON about this subject, I might on my own page later today, but for now I will just say “Right On Sista!!!”  **hugs**

  • It was my understanding that the “health of the mother” issue was mocked as it was not because there are pregnancies that include a true risk to the mother – as yours was – but because the doctor who will do the abortion determines whether or not the mother’s health is in danger. And since the term “health of the mother” can be stretched as needed (and I’m sure it has been on occasion), the term was mocked.

    But you are right. McCain should not have mocked the women who have gone through that situation.

    And there are enough couples unable to have children out there to care for the unwanted babies that are “ended prematurely.” At least, that’s the way I see it.

  • @TreeHouseTruths - I agree that it was probably McCain’s intent to mock only the times that health of the mother has been used as an excuse rather than an actual medical issue.  The problem as I see it is that if laws are written to “close that loophole” then the law applies to everyone. 

  • You should mail this to Sen. McCain and Sen. Obama and see if you become as famous as “Joe the Plumber.”  Excellent points all around.

  • I agree with you that the Roe vs. Wade decision has been made, and it’s time to move on.  I hate that women use abortion as a form of birth control.  I want to be more open-minded and progressive and say that I’m totally pro-choice, but I can’t.  However, illegalizing abortion doesn’t make it go away.  It just forces women to go to back-alley clinics where there is no guarantee that the procedure will be done safely.  Fighting against R v. W is a waste of time.  If pro-lifers want to make a difference, they should take another tack.  What about low-cost, low-hormone, over the counter birth control?  What about increasing education about the prevention of unwanted pregnancies?  What about some frigging compassion for people who have a good reason to end a pregnancy early?  What about providing more available care for young, scared, confused, pregnant women?  What about making vasectomies and similar measures more affordable, more accessible?  What about doing something novel and using both heart and mind to make decisions?

Post a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *