March 8, 2008
-
You Knew I Was a Snake ...
Has everyone heard the story of the boy and the snake?
A snake crawled high on the mountain, not noticing the falling temperature until suddenly his blood cooled too much and he was almost frozen. On the verge of death, he sees a boy also climbing the mountain and pleads with the boy to carry him down to the warmer rocks of the valley. The boy feels pity, but resists the plea because this snake is a venomous one. The snake promises, begging for his life that he won't bite the boy if he will just carry him down to safety. The boy gives in, carries the snake to safety and as the snake becomes warm in the boy's shirt he focuses on the beat of the heart beneath that warm skin. Before the snake has time to consider, his fangs come out and sink deep into the boy's chest, filling that heart with deadly venom. As the boy lays dying the snake crawls away saying, "you knew when you picked me up ..."
Co-dependency has been the theme of the week around here. I've had conversations with friends, relatives and people I don't even know all describing situations in which they so want to help but realize that they have instead enabled their loved ones to continue in destructive behavior.
One friend told me of how her attempts to love her husband have not resulted in the reciprocal relationship she desires. Instead, the more she gives, the more he takes while she spends her days lonely and her nights wishing for more. One friend described a situation with an adult child who has given her grandchildren, but fails to parent those children well, and in fact neglects and emotionally abuses the kids. So my friend often "babysits" in order to give the kids a place of stability and security even though she knows that she is enabling her child to continue in immature and abusive behavior. A third friend is in a situation with an adult child that is probably going to cost my friend close to $20,000 not counting legal fees before its all over, and the child is very likely to serve time in jail for bad decisions made. Another friend was forced to file bankruptcy this week over a car loan she co-signed. The other party defaulted on the loan and the car was repossessed without her having been informed of the problem. Now her credit is trashed and she's being sued for the balance of the loan, which she can't afford to pay.
I used to hear more stories of co-dependence with a partner who couldn't shake bad habits. Now, as much because of my age and that of my friends as anything I hear more and more stories of parents who know they are enabling negative behavior in their adult children but can't seem to break the cycle. Especially because they seem so helpless in the face of choices they can't understand. After all they never made THESE mistakes. They don't understand how their kids can be making these choices now, or why the kids don't seem to care about the damage they are creating in the lives of the people around them.
Finally, you come to the place voiced by one of the people described above, "I don't care anymore 'what he was thinking' there's nothing I can do about his thinking anyway."
Dr. Phil describes a situation in this month's Oprah magazine of a woman who was unfaithful to her husband. She repented of the infidelity and realized that she truly loves her husband. So she came back and has dedicated herself to restoring the marriage, but the husband can't get over it. Although he says that he loves her, he doesn't trust her and has begun to behave toward her in ways that can fairly be described as abusive. As with all tragic human relationships the bottom line there is that either the woman can sign up for a life-sentence of guilt, recrimination and abuse as her just due for having betrayed her husband's trust, or she can move on. There is no middle ground. Changing his behavior is not an option for her to choose (although he can choose it, she can't choose change for him). And in fact, the more often she allows him to behave in an abusive manner, the more likely he is to repeat that behavior.
You know, I'm aware that "birds of a feather flock together". So when I sense a trend in the lives of my friends I take a look at myself because my friends aren't just randomly chosen or conscripted into friendship without some commonality attracting me to them.
We love our partners. We love our kids. And we want so desperately for them to love us back, to respect us, to be good people, make good decisions, we want them to reach out and hold us. But none of us can compel these qualities in another. The more we try to "provoke them to good works" the more they seem to take our solicitation as license to behave in the same old way and then some.
I may yet have these issues with my boys. They are certainly not immune from bad decisions and I love them so much that its easy for me to be blind to a problem until it's reached a point of crisis. One thing that I'm trying to live by is a rule I adopted when they were much younger, "Never routinely do something for another person that he is capable of doing for himself." Of course I will cook meals, do laundry, and a hundred other things that my boys are capable of, but I also pull them into the rotation of chores so they aren't learning that I will automatically and routinely handle things for them.
Its been especially difficult with Michael because of the challenges presented by his autism to know when to let him take his lumps and when to step in and ask for leniency. The kid tries, and most of the time is recognized by his teachers as one who tries very hard. But sometimes they miss something that means his best effort doesn't look like much, and then he needs help from his advocate (me) in negotiating his way through the world. As he's getting older I'm also teaching him to advocate for himself, and that's a whole new level of tricky.
Another rule that I've adopted for myself after hearing Dawn's description of it is: Don't offer them solutions for their problems. Acknowledge their frustration, but give it back to them, "How do YOU intend to solve that? What's YOUR plan for fixing this? What will YOU do next?" Even if you can see so clearly what they could do to fix it, let them decide how to proceed. That's important for two reasons, first it gets you out of that enabling behavior and second, it comminucates to the person that you believe in them and trust them to be able to handle it.
My kids don't look like snakes. I'm pretty sure they aren't venomous. It's not apparent to me that their nature is to harm. My friends' kids didn't look like snakes when they were 11 and 13 either. But the road that has led to a place where my friends seem to have no choice in the matter, they either enable or allow the grandkids to suffer, enable or allow the child to go to jail, enable or allow the child to face financial consequences, enable or allow ...
And it's a false choice. We aren't allowing anything. They are going to do what they are going to do. I'm not a big Dr. Phil fan because he strikes me as arrogant and uncaring much of the time but he's not all wrong. He says "when you choose the behavior, you choose the consequence." The hardest part of parenting may be that we have to get out of the way of the consequences our children have chosen, and we have to be wise enough to limit our own risk in the process.
If you know that your kid has a drug problem, don't co-sign a loan for them. If you can't afford to pay for the car, don't co-sign the note. (I am more and more opposed to being a co-signer on anything for any reason. I'd loan or give money before I'd co-sign and risk my own financial position.) Certainly don't agree to be a joint account holder. And if you ARE a joint account holder or co-signer, move as quickly as possible to get out of that legal entanglement. (Note to all who haven't thought about this, if you have a joint account with someone you are legally responsible for any bad debt that person creates with that account whether you wrote the bad check or not.)
Love your kids. Love your spouse. Love your friend. But be smart. Don't expose yourself to losses you can't afford. Don't buy into the myth that it will be better later.
Comments (16)
Amen.
For most of my life, it was difficult for me to see snakes anyplace at all, and even when I saw them, I never dreamed they might be poisonous, and certainly never thought they'd bite me, even if they were supposedly 'harmless' varieties. It took me picking up a few, holding them close to my heart, even letting one or two live in it a while, caring and trusting and believing in them, and the promises to not bite, and then finding the fangs embedded before I figured out that the best guide really is instinct, but you have to first GET the instinct..not everyone has it at birth...and pay attention to it once you have it. Now, if it looks like a snake, (or is even wormlike,) the last thing I do is hold it close. Hopefully that'll get me to the end of my life without any more deeply embedded fang marks.
Some never seem to get the instinct, and just keep getting the bites. I think there should be classes for them or something...I sure wish there had been some for me a lot earlier than I finally 'got' it myself.
Codependency is a control issue. We say "Let me do it for you I know you can't do it." It is just plain not respectful of the other person. Judi
I'm not sure how I feel after reading this, I can relate so much to it...
Ryc: I believe we do waste time using all these methods to save it. lol, Judi
Such a hard lesson to learn when we want to believe the best in others.
I agree that your advice there at the end is prudent, but some of those situations you cited are sticky. The grandmother providing a haven for the youngest generation could be doing a service for not just those kids, but for the society in which they will live.
"...losses you can't afford." is the operant phrase there. Willing sacrifice for a worthy purpose is one thing, useless waste and blatant enabling are something else. Human relations are never simple, eh?
We've heard insanity is doing the same thing over expecting different results. It's not true in all cases, but most always concering codependency! Gosh, this is a soapbox of mine. I have a friend that could write the book here (she wasn't a parent until late in her life, which led to overcompensating, I believe.) Her son ended up being a monster.. fast (he's in rehab... pray for his recovery!) He always said it was her fault and that ended up being the sad, self-fulfilling prophecy.
I've had a hard time with my grown children not being as responsible as they should be. They live under my roof (which I always said I'd do because they are putting themselves through college because we think they will appreciate it more) so it's hard to not wake them, knowing they will be late, etc. A friend says they should act like they are guests in my home and I disagree... I think they should take part like the live here (cos they do!)
Anyway, I think this problem with our culture has happened because we have defined love wrongly: we think it means to make life easier for others than we had it ourselves (particularly true of our children who have entirely too many THINGS instead of caring parents.) Love often has to be tough. I have a (nameless) child who to guilt me for pointing out the truth of her occasional lack of character... I only do it because I care enough that she work on correcting it. I love her too much to leave her like that.
While, I am bloggin' in your comments, I will say one more thing. I have a friend who has quite a bit of insight into human nature. He tells a story about a man with a handicapped daughter who stumbles and spills her crayons. The father runs to her, says he's sorry and picks up the crayons for her and as a result the child collapses in tears... not because she's hurt physically, but she's hurt emotionally because she was not allowed to repair the problem herself.
lol, i outcommented the box size...
@ZincWhiskers - You can blog here any day! Everything you said added value to my blog. Thank you!
@SuSu - Human relationships aren't simple, or easy. I wondered when I wrote this whether I'd ended where I intended because all the advice on avoiding co-dependence assumes that we are able to recognize when we are engaging in risky behavior and I wanted to show that for most of it, that's only clear in hindsight.
I agree with what you said about the grandmother watching her grandkids (and she does too) even though she knows that filling in the gaps for her son is in part enabling his irresponsibility, she's not inclined to put the babies at risk even if its co-dependence on her part.
@RnBoW_SPOT - It's not easy to sort out what to do and when the help is really helping. We do want to believe the best of others and I think that's been a key in every one of the situations that my friends have found themselves in. The other key though is to ask yourself, "If that person respected me, and wanted what is best for me, would she ASK me to co-sign that loan?"
@jassmine - It took me a long time to learn that co-dependent enabling was disrespectful. And I can put this one on my mother
I grew up with a mother who demanded that I perform "rescuing" type services for her and if I didn't (which was never an option) or if I didn't do it fast enough, (which was frequently a possibility) I was punished and given the guilt trip.
So I have had a very hard time as an adult separating healthy from co-dependent behavior. I learned the lesson well that allowing another person to simply be responsible for him/herself was unloving, unkind, uncaring, hard-hearted, and a host of other negative character qualities that I didn't want to be.
@quiltnmomi - I grew up in the same kind of home codependent that is then continued it in my marriage. It took what it took for me to learn years of it. Now I am still codependent with my children at times. Judi
Wonderful thesis here dear one. I tried, not very completely to remember what I picked up somewhere along the way, "To solve a problem for a child is to rob them of potential IQ points, to allow them to wrestle with the problem on their own promotes wisdom."
sigh.
you ARE right.
Comments are closed.