July 23, 2003

  • Ruling Ourselves


    I've been thinking about rules.  It seems to me that a significant portion of parenting is strictly devoted to identifying rules.  From the day you bring the baby home from the hospital you begin to realize there are rules you never considered but which you will disregard to your peril.  I think the first RULE that we discovered was Never allow cool air to enter the baby's diaper area.  I don't know if it works the same for baby girls as it does for baby boys, but the second that diaper is opened, they experience this reflexive shoot first and ask questions later phenomenon.  We got really good at changing the diaper without ever allowing the baby to be in an unclothed state. 


    At every stage so far there have been new rules to live by.  At six and nine, the rules that most concern them now are the rules of socialization.  It's one of the things every homeschooling family hears, "But what about their socialization!"  This betrays a fundamental lack of awareness about what socialization entails.  To be socialized is to internalize the "rules" that make it possible to live together with other people.  It isn't necessary to throw kids into a big pool of other unsocialized little critters and wait back while they sort it all out although that's primarily the way we've done it for the past hundred years or so.  At just the age that kids start being concerned one way or the other with whether they are liked, whether they have playmates, whether they can get along with their teachers and impress the people in authority over them - we send them off to school without giving them the benefit of a rulebook they can consult when the going gets rough. 


    I'm not saying that homeschool allows kids to circumvent the process of trial and error that will occasionally have them making the same kind of mistakes that every novice will make and have to learn from.  What homeschool does is put the parent right there beside the child 24 hours a day helping them figure out the rules.  Essentially, the same rules that children need to learn are the rules that we all must live by if we are going to interact with other people.  We need to know 1) how to make friends  2) how to achieve popularity and 3) how to behave politically, the rules of socialization guide us to our ultimate succes or failure in these three areas. 


    My kids are very concerned right now with externally imposed rules.  They want to know who made that rule and what its purpose might be.  We've talked about speed limits and taxes to illustrate the fact that even grown-ups have externally imposed guidelines with consequences for ignoring those guidelines.  I'm more concerned with whether they are internatlizing the rules.  It doesn't warm my heart much at all if I hear Tucker say, "I can't bite you because there's a sign posted on my wall that says "no biting".  On the other hand, when I heard him say to the cat, "I can't bite you because you have feelings and it's wrong for me to hurt you."  THAT makes me a happy Momi.  (And yes, Tucker has indeed bitten the cat before on multiple occasions which is another blog entirely.)   


    Out of consideration for your time and appreciation for the fact that you've read this far!  I won't get into the specifics of the rules of socialization, today.  Consider this an introduction and tomorrow I'll get into the meat of the matter. 


    *********************


    I tried to visit people yesterday and had a disturbing experience.  I clicked on the links in my SIR list and was sent to bizarre places in the backwaters of Xanga that I had never seen before.  I kid you not, I was going to comment on my friend Kris, and I wound up at a site devoted to Hell.  After the fourth or fifth of these excursions into surreality, I gave up.  I'm sorry.  It was just messing with my head too badly.  Today, I very much hope that Xanga has fixed that bug.  And I'll be around to see where you've really been hanging out.         

Comments (36)

  • And when I see unruly kids in public, I ask myself what rules of socialization they were taught.

    Or NOT taught!

  • I sort of liked that bug (which, incidentally, only seemed to lead one astray when clicking on the actual name; the comments led one to the correct place -- or so it seemed for me).  I got to some v-e-r-y interesting places, including, serendipitously, the great "secret" blog of someone I'm subbed to elsewhere!    However.  I did NOT go to Hell.  Sheesh!

    I was thinking about my own "rules" blog this morning.  It won't appear today (unless I'm a real lazy girl at work, which I can't be).  Fortunately, I took a different tack.  But this one was excellent.  As ever!

  • Hi,

    Very nice Blog. Lots of  Rules. Different ones for each household, community, city, state, country. And kids/people figure them out. Says a lot about the ability for humans to adapt.

    Looking forward to your next Blog.

    Rich

  • Yep, I too, was sent to many odd places yesterday and can only hope I am me again today!!

    I really liked this post... I am looking forward to the next part. And about hearing the cat story too

  • Hey! I got sent to places unknown as well, but the head Xanga's said that they got the bugs fixed.   I liked your blog on rules and can't wait to read what you have to say about socialization!

  • I don't have any kids, but if I did, I think the last place I'd send them is public school.  The drawbacks of home-schooling are far outweighed by the benefits to both the kids and the parents, it seems to me.

    --Scott

  • One concept that caught my attention was the idea that you are put in a room with 20 (or more probably) people your age.  It's a false experience of the world where you are around people of all different ages.

  • I'm sorry, but I'm still laughing that I finally do a Soul Food blog and that's where you end up. Too ironic... I didn't have problems with it yesterday at all, and my SIR list is showing in the proper "they just wrote" order in my sub page, so I'm hoping like crazy it's fixed now.

    In complete agreement with you on the rules. I remember being a kid and thinking how glad I would be when I grew up and could live without rules. I had no idea...

  • The SIR list seems ok for me today although it was weird yesterday.  Excellent thought-provoking blog (but then, your's usually are).

    I homeschooled for a year. It was enough  

  • xanga did have some wacky voodoo going on.

    rules rules rules.... if they don't make sense, they don't make sense.  dammit.   However.... I do see the importance of socialization in situations where there are no rule books.  and these days most schools do give rules--it's called a Student Handbook, where the expectations of what is acceptable social behavior is outlined. 

    I have to say I am concerned with that aspect of homeschooling, that perhaps children wouldn't get enough social interaction... however.  Since I don't believe school should be a social setting, but rather a place for obtaining an education, it most definitely is not a predominant factor in obtaining a successful education. 

    Would you say, if you only had one child at home, that it would be a healthy environment for him to be schooled a full education?

  • You know, during that weird name-substitution episode, your entries were showing up on my SIR page under the name of bondlife.  It was unsettling.

    Love what you've said so far about socialization, and I'm looking forward to the rest.

  • R - Oh, wow.  I like bondlife, so if I had to be swapped around with someone, I'm glad it was Paul.

  • Is that why I pee reflexively in air conditioned rooms?

  • I would love to Homeschool my little girl but I really just don't think I have what it takes.  You sound so wise and I think that is the most important factor.  I just don't have all those teaching techniques that come so easy to some.  I think it's so wonderful that you are able to be with your children like that. 

    I have yet to come in to contact with any bad pages on Xanga and I will be extra careful so that it doesn't happen.  I know how you feel about things being very upsetting...I try not to go anywhere that I am not sure about on the internet...

    Have a great day!

  • Daff - you make good points in your comment and raise exceelent questions.  A couple things I'd like to clarify - the point at which children first become attuned to the need/benefit of learning how to relate to other people is usually around age 5-6 when they couldn't read a handbook even if one were available.  The rules I'm talking about are the unwritten codes of conduct that we must all muddle out.  And whether the homeschool family has one child or a dozen, the process of guiding each individual through the socialization process requires parental awareness and vigilance.  I think that all parents owe it to their kids to put them in situations where they have an opportunity to interact with people of all ages, and as much as possible from diverse backgrounds. 

  • I've not been blogging much lately......sounds like I missed out on the "fun".  Looking forward to more on the "rules."  I got your e-mail.  That address is still okay....I just haven't spent much time on the computer lately.

  • Very interesting.  Be sure that you tell them that not only do adults have rules, but that they have MORE rules than any kid ever imagined. 

  • yesterday, the xanga twilight zone visited my SIR's as well. I gave up after ending up in some scary places. I think it's fixed finally today

  • Great, great insight!  o/

    God Bless - Dale o/

  • i'm assuming when your SIR sent you to hellblog, you were referring to mine. 

    it's cuz i've done such a poor job of socializing my brats... erm, precious offspring, isn't it? 

    *hangs head in shame.*

  • props !!

  • Love your def of socialization.  Wonder what was up with xanga?  I missed that one and think I am glad of it.  Hope your day was great!

  • Thank You, Thank You Thank You I had stopped using the word "socalization" because every time I used it everyone got ready for a party.  As a trained sociologist I was appalled- but finally gave up-- I think I ran out of wine. .

    I was commenting to a friend the other day that a distinction I notice between children raised in Asian families and in European/American is that the latter tends to think parenting is instinctive. Clearly You recognize there is more.  Along that line I have been impressed to learn that Asian parents sit side by side with their offspring as their children learn our language, math, science, etc., with formidable results, yet the parents in some instances did.do not speak English, could not read and could do only basic math. Great blog.

    Love and Light

    Mara

  • Congrats on getting featured..Just leavin some props...Take care.xoxo...

    ~*Keri*~

  • as usual there is much to digest and react to here, but my number one thought is: what is happening these days that even the most common rules of decency are getting ignored?

    and have i been blogging so much less lately that i haven't even experienced that merry mix-up on my SIR?

  • Oh! I need to impress that "the cat has feelings" thingy.  I caught Ashley trying to kick her brother's cat (she has her own) the other day "because he's not my cat."  That blows me away!

  • You did a fantastic job on your page.  Looks great.  I'd love to say rules suck..who needs them. But, we all need some kind of rules otherwise it would just be chaos.

    I tried visiting yesterday but like you said, I went elsewhere.  I just kept getting the xanga bug page.

    Have a great day

  • Keep writing

  • I do not enjoy rules. I know there is a better way. You have a great open mind when it comes to children. I did not expericence adults like you as a child...as for the back waters, that is creepy. That would make me creep out too. People who are openly "dark" are a big issue with me. I just feel my energy get all "weirded out." Luckily I have never ran across anything as harsh as you described, or the KKK ones, some have blogged about. These are issues for me. Peace and Blessings

  • Good discourse. Looking forward to the next installments, as always.

    I've had trouble with my SIR list on my site, but the daily emails seem to be working OK. Mike

  • I just wanted to let you know that you have a beautifully designed site and that I am soo new at this.  It is truly an inspiration and plan to take time to come back and read more!!

  • I just wanted to say what a beautifully designed site and I am soo new at this!!  I definitely want to spend some time reading and will be coming back real soon...Your site is an inspiration...

  • All right! A blog that talks about homeschooling! My attitude is on the radical end. As far as I'm concerned, school does little BUT harm kids, in so many ways. Being with people who truly love them and truly have their personal interests at heart is the best thing for children. Life should be about love -- spending time with those whom we love to be with and who love us, and doing what we love to do -- not about being taken from those who love you, surviving in a cruel atmosphere, and being forced to learn about meaningless things. When my daughter was in school, the only time I got to spend with her during the week was in the struggle to get her ready to go in the morning, in the struggle to get her to do her homework at night and get ready for bed, and during dinner -- the *few* truly free and enjoyable minutes we got together. Parents don't give themselves enough credit for what they can give their children. No "experts" needed.

  • My son is due at the end of the month. THANK YOU FOR THE DIAPER WARNING> I was aware that they sometimes peed up at you, but I didn't know why or when...ah hahhha now I can avoid it! Thanks again.

  • weird...

    I have never had THAT bug happen to me...  not in 2 1/2-plus years.

    I think a lot of today's kids are improperly socialized BECAUSE they have such poor supervision...  but that's just me, maybe.

Comments are closed.

Post a Comment